signpost iconVirus 'kills prostate cancer'

Bottom Line:

This is a news feature regarding the discoveru of a virus that "kills off" prostate cancer cells.

Publication details:

The article discusses an early report of a new type of treatment for prostate cancer.

We assessed this page using an appraisal instrument developed by Minervation specifically for this project. This approach is still in development, so you should regard the assessments as a general guide. Click here to find out more, or to let us know how you think the approach could be improved.

Reliability comments:

  • The content has been checked.
  • The page is a news item from 10 March 2010.
  • The page cites some relevant sources.
  • It is clear who has developed the website and what their objectives are.
  • The site reports a robust editorial policy that includes critical appraisal of sources.
  • Information is provided by a multidisciplinary team of clinicians.

Usability comments:

  • The format is clear
  • No login is needed to access the site.
  • The pages are busy and overloaded with information.
  • There are many competing navigational tools and the search engine is error-prone.

Scoring

Reliability
Item Score
Is it clear who has developed the web site and what their objectives are? 3
It is clear who has developed the website and what their objectives are.
Does the site report a robust quality control procedure? 3
Is the page content checked by an expert? 3
The content has been checked.
Is the page updated regularly? 2
The page is a news item from 10 March 2010.
Does the page cite relevant sources where appropriate? 2
The page cites some relevant sources.
Usability
Item Score
Is the site accessible without a login? 3
No login is needed to access the site.
Does the site conform to web Accessibility standards? 3
The site scores 93% for accessibility.
Is the site design clear and transparent? 2
The pages are busy and overloaded with information.
Is the site design consistent from one page to another? 2
The site design is not consistent.
Can users find what they need on the site? 1
The site is sometimes difficult to navigate and the search engine is error prone.
Is the format of information clear and appropriate for the audience? 3
The format is clear and appropriate for the audience.
Weighted total (Usability + (Reliability x 2)): 40
We score each question out of three where:
0 = Never or Can't tell
1 = Sometimes or partly
2 = Mostly
3 = Always

Date rated

Source

NHS Choices

Currency

Adequate

Audience

Patients, Health Professionals

Publication Type

News

Format

Web page

Reliability

5 stars

Usability

4.5 stars

Find: Similar

Contact us about this summary

Your comment or question:
G6H3KW